Giants 21, Cowboys 17. It does not matter how it turned out that way, but all that matters was that the Giants got that "W" and advanced. This is one of the most disappointing losses in Dallas Cowboys history, and sure is why I have a site like this. If one word could be used to describe the Dallas Cowboys franchise over the past decade it would certainly be 'frustrating.' Going into the matchup with the Giants, a team which the Cowboys had already beaten twice this season, the average fan would think that the Cowboys would have the upper hand.
d. Beating a team twice in one season is always difficult, so confidence-wise the Cowboys must have had an edge. Tony Romo also had the greatest season ever for a Cowboys quarterback, breaking the touchdown and pass completion records. Jason Witten, the Cowboys tight end, had the 3rd greatest season in the history of the NFL for his position, and the best overall for any Cowboys tight end. The Cowboys also were sending 12 players to the Pro-Bowl. I'm sure any of those guys would trade a trip to Hawaii for a trip to Phoenix for the Superbowl, but they just did not get the job done. The Cowboys fell to the Giants because of the recurring problems they have had all season long, as the Giants exposed several of the Cowboys mental and disciplinary deficiencies.
If you want to see a mentally tough team, then take a look at the New England Patriots. The San Diego Chargers are also a good example. When Tom Brady gets hit or flustered, you would never know it by the look on his face. He is always a stone cold focused quarterback, and does not let adversity ever get in the way of his drive to win. The Chargers faced a great Colts team, the defending Superbowl champs, and without LT for 3 quarters and a gimpy Antonio Gates they managed to pull out a stunning victory over the Colts. When the Chargers were down and out, they came together as a team and found a way to win. That did not happen with the Cowboys, as they practically imploded on the field mentally. Visually, it was easy to see that they could not get out of the hole they had dug themselves, and they could not find a way to withstand the Giants' attack by responding with mental toughness.
As usual, the Cowboys were the most penalized team on the field, getting flagged 11 times for over 80 yards. That is flat out inexcusable, as several of these penalties came by way of false starts, facemasks, and personal fouls for unnecessary roughness. Although I understand that DeMarcus Ware was just trying to get a nice jump on Eli Manning's snap, there is no excuse for his prolonging the drive by jumping offsides. The play was broken up and the Giants were about to punt, but Ware's costly penalty resulted in an eventual and improbable Amani Toomer 52-yard touchdown catch. This was not the first time Ware had jumped offsides like this, as I can recall it happening at least 3 or 4 times thoughout the season, and the Cowboys never sat him down to fix the problem.
Just before the end of the half, 48 seconds to be exact, the Cowboys were poised to go into halftime with a 14-7 lead. That all changed when Jacques Reeves decided to get a personal foul, 15-yard facemask on the Giant he was trying to tackle out of bounds. The receiver was already going out of bounds, so there was no need to grab that facemask. All he had to do was tackle correctly and force him out. This was no aberration by Reeves, as he has played poor defense the entire season. He has clearly shown that he is incapable of being a 3rd corner, and needs to be replaced. Who would I replace him with you may ask? How about Anthony Henry, who has clearly shown that he cannot be a starter in this league. But what about Henry's position, who would I replace him with? How about getting Asante Samule in free agency. If the Cowboys ever want to win a playoff game, then they need to get Samuel.
Obviously the outcome of this game does not belong on the shoulders of Ware and Reeves' dumb plays, but how about the atrocious play of the Dallas offensive line? I'm not talking about Kozier or Columbo; I'm talking about the 3 pro-bowlers: Flozell Adams, Andre Gurode, and Leonard Davis. Once again, Flozell Adams managed to jump offsides several times againt the Giants. This also is not an aberration, as he has done this a countless number of times this season. I do not know what it is, but Adams has a serious problem with concentration. He is easily the most penalized lineman in the NFL, which is flat out inexcusable for a man of his size and talent. Now on to Leonard Davis, who's personal foul on Michael Strahan took away a Romo pass completion that would have landed the Cowboys on the Giant's 33-yard line. That was terrible, pathetic, and inexcusable. Strahan was down on the ground, and although I do not like him as a person, Davis still had no right to make that play. It was an easy flag to get, and it clearly showed that he was not being disciplined as a lineman.
Andre Gurode will get his own paragraph for his terrible play on Sunday. I have never seen a pro-bowl center have so much trouble snapping the ball while in the shotgun formation. This can't be a physical problem, since the ball weighs nothing and he can bench over 500 lbs I bet, so this has to be a mental problem. Gurode's bad snaps have come in all shapes and sizes. There's the over the head snap, the worst of them all, that did not occur vs. the Giants. Then there is the floater snap, the one that seems to take FOREVER to get to a grasping and flustered Romo. Then there is the bullet snap, which usually goes to the right or left of Romo, but never directly to his chest. If I were the Cowboys coaches, I would paint a target on a wall and have Gurode snap to that target 100 times a day. If he hits 90% of his snaps then he gets a Texas-sized steak or something, but if not, then more snaps until he gets it right. That problem of his is not too difficult to correct, and it really has to be very annoying for Romo because he never knows what he will get. The slow floater snap also helped Osi Umenyiora and Strahan immensely in their pass rushes. So Gurode, you played a massive role in the Cowboys' historic loss, and I sincerely hope you work on your snapping in the offseason. I hope you are working on them right now, seriously.
Instead of pointing out another particular player, I would like to now shine the spotlight on the entire Cowboys special teams unit, who's pathetic play vs. the Giants (and pretty much all season long), cost the Cowboys the playoff game. Two of the Giants' touchdown scores resulted from a short field, as the Cowboys allowed a 50-yard kickoff return after they went up 14-7, and another huge punt return that would eventually lead to the Giants going ahead for good. As with Reeves' terrible coverage and Adams' awful false starts, the Cowboys' special teams unit did not have a fluke of a game by playing so badly against the Giants. All season long they had let teams back into games by giving up huge returns, and that is just a terrible thing to have happen. It deflates both the offense and especially the defense, as no defender likes to walk onto a short field. Bad kickoff and punt coverage also destroys momentum, which happend several times in the Cowboys vs. Giants game. The bad overall coverage certainly played a huge role in the Giants' victory, and every member on the Cowboys' special teams should be ashamed of themselves. They played with no heart, no desire, and poor ability.
Last, but certainly not least, let's talk about our team big-mouth: Patrick Crayton. First of all, as Keyshawn Johnson so eloquently put it, Crayton won his position by default. If not for Terry Glenn's injury, Crayton would not have had a chance to start. He put up very average numbers this season, and would not be the lead receiver on any team in the NFL. Second of all, and this annoys me to a horrible extent, Crayton just loves to talk trash. He always takes the media's bait and goes off on all subjects, whether it is making snyde comments about Roy Williams' horse collar suspension or giving the Giants all the bulletin board material they need. Worst of all, Crayton does not even have close enough to the amount of talent needed to be able to backup what he says. If you look at the Patriots, they hardly ever talk trash in the media. It is just not them, and whatever they do stays in the locker room. Crayton has made himself an open forum, and I am getting sick of it. If he ever backed up his comments then I would care a little less, but against the Giants he did not come close. Crayton had a shot at a touchdown run after the catch, but dropped the sidearm throw by Romo and forced the Cowboys to punt. On another possession, Crayton had a chance at a 40-yard touchdown catch in the endzone, yet decided to stutter step and stop running. He had a jump on the Giants' corner, and if he had kept running then he would have had a sure touchdown grab. That is two passes that Crayton could have taken for TD's, yet he did not take advantage of the opportunities presented to him. Just like his fellow couterparts, he was not mentally tough and choked under the pressure. Also, when the Cowboys were down 21-17 and had the Giants backed up and punting from their own endzone, Crayton fumbled the punt at the Dallas 40-yard line. He had plenty of room, and could have returned the ball to at least mid-field, yet his mental choke cost the Cowboys a shot at great field position. Because of Crayton's play on Sunday, the Cowboys could not have hoped to win the game. He did everything he could to prevent that from happening, so hopefully he learns to keep his mouth shut in the future and let his play do the talking. That seems to work out well for the undefeated Patriots, or any other team still left in the playoffs.
If there's one central theme to pick up from this article about the Cowboys loss, it is that they simply did not perform well mentally to give themselves a chance at winning. The Cowboys could have all the physical talent in the world, which they had loads more than the Giants, but all the little things count greatly as well. Tackling correctly and not getting facemask calls counts. Knowing the snap count is huge. Snapping the ball efficiently to the quarterback, which does not seem to be that hard to do, also appears to be a very significant factor to the success of plays. Catching passes, especially touchdown passes, is also major.
Discipline wise, the Cowboys were just not all there. Romo had to resort to yelling at his lineman at the end of the game, and when I saw that I knew it was not going to end well. The Cowboys nearly won the game at the end, but should have never been in that position in the first place. If their special teams would have been disciplined and not run up field past the blocks, then maybe the Giants would not have had two touchdowns. All the little things count in the NFL, and if teams refuse to take them into consideration they get burned.
The Cowboys got burned, as did their fans, and the Giants' game is just another contribution to the last 12 years of frustration.
In 1994, Troy Aikman and the Cowboys had a chance to win 3 Superbowls in a row, but they did not do the little things required to beat the SF 49ers in the NFC championship game. The following year they pulled together and won their 3rd and last title. That game was also the Cowboys last meaningful playoff victory. Will the Romo-led Cowboys of today pull together as Troy, Emmitt, and Michael Irvin did in the past? Or will they fall apart next season?
Only time will tell.